We visited both Lookout Cay at Lighthouse Point and Castaway Cay on the same Disney Cruise Line sailing and compared them head-to-head across food, vibes, activities, shopping, and navigation. Here’s which island came out on top.

Our last day aboard the Disney Treasure was a special one, with a trip to Castaway Cay that included lunch, snorkeling and a 5K, our final dinner at Plaza de Coco and Beauty and the Beast, our final Broadway-style entertainment on the ship.

We had a unique stop in this cruise itinerary, a trip to Lookout Cay at Lighthouse Point to replaced the canceled Falmouth, Jamaica port stop due to the damage done by the hurricanes.